5This new revelation perspective plus the standard meaning of that it verse is not, not, with the matter of wedding to non-Muslims. New traditional interpretation states this verse was actually shown whenever one or two polytheist men from Quraish requested its siblings becoming right back, Oum Kelthoum and you may Bint Aqabah, when they had transformed into Islam and you will moved in order to Medina into the buy to join the Muslim community.
It general idea is not always real plus the “strength” or even the “weakness” of the religious trust is not associated with gender however, instead on the individuals identity and character
It is really worth reminding the Prophet signed at the time a binding agreement named Al-Hudaybya Pact toward opposing group away from Quraish to eliminate the brand new conflict to have ten years. It contract specified, yet others, that one Quraychit girl who would get in on the Prophet when you look at the Medina without any permission of their judge teacher shall be sent back so you’re able to Mecca.
Oum Kelthoum, who had been the only person to alter to help you Islam inside her relatives, and you may just who fled from of the most extremely intense environments, begged the brand new Prophet not to repatriate their so you can the lady group so since the to not be launched once more to their unfair therapy.
This new verse aforementioned was then revealed to get rid of this new extradition of females whom transformed into Islam and prevent the fresh revenge from their particular families. Hence, the latest Prophet refused to posting right back brand new exiled females on the opposition, while the arrangement is handled for men.
The rationale of verse above mentioned shows that it can maybe not deal with in any way the wedding so you can low-Muslims, but was rather revealed to meet some proper standards away from protecting ladies who converted to Islam from the will of the household members and exactly who voluntarily requested the fresh new Prophet’s safety.
The fresh paradox that people highlight on these ancient perceptions concerns brand new fact that according to such students, Muslim women are banned to help you get married “disbelievers” in addition to Religious and you may Jewish males, if you find yourself to the question of Muslim men, Christian and you can Jewish women are regarded as believers. How can we envision, in the same Christian or Jewish area, one men are disbelievers while people of the identical teams is believers?
Regarding absence of one proof you to definitely warrants the new prohibition off the wedding out of Muslim people on the followers out-of almost every other monotheistic religions, the latest contemporary students validate the thinking because of the “the new sheer exhaustion” off Muslim women that might have to go astray according to the “bad” determine of its Religious or Jewish husbands. But the Muslim guy could possibly take over his Christian or Jewish spouse and you may include his kid’s and individual believe.
The newest Qur’anic verse, dealing with the marriage out of Muslim women or men to help you believers regarding most other religions, set particular statutes playing with a keen egalitarian code
Indeed, the disagreement isn’t convincing as if the newest told you verse forbids the wedding anywhere interracialdatingcentral ceny between a Muslim lady and you can an effective Religious otherwise Jewish kid as it’s unanimously interpreted now, thus eg marriage is even forbidden to your Muslim guy. However, considering some Qur’anic verses and the Islamic stability, Christians and Jews are believed unanimously while the believers belonging to religions found because of the Allah long lasting current differences in terms of brand new dogma plus the theological viewpoints.
This means that, the study of the verse means that the fresh Qur’an prohibits the wedding regarding both Muslim men and women to polytheists.
However it is worth bringing up one to students agree unanimously for the ban of the relationships out of a good Muslim girl in order to good Jewish or Religious, while zero an element of the Qur’an provides for instance ban one to justifies so it discrimination.